Buckeye Pizza

Discover delicious pan pizza with a variety of toppings at Buckeye Pizza in Plain City, OH. Enjoy friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere. Call +1 614-873-0780 to order or visit us at 209 W Bigelow Ave!

Welcome to Buckeye Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Plain City, Buckeye Pizza serves up mouth-watering pizza and classic Italian comfort food. With its warm, inviting atmosphere, this local favorite draws in families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts looking for a satisfying meal. Buckeye Pizza specializes in pan pizza piled high with toppings, ensuring each bite bursts with flavor. The friendly staff pride themselves on providing excellent service, creating a welcoming community vibe where everyone feels at home. Whether it’s a casual dinner or a gathering with friends, this pizzeria offers a slice of happiness for all. Located conveniently at 209 W Bigelow Ave, Buckeye Pizza is the go-to spot for delicious food and good company.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

209 W Bigelow Ave, Plain City, OH 43064, United States

Phone

+1 614-873-0780

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Pizza

Buckeye Pizza has established itself as a staple in Plain City since opening its doors. The owner recognized the need for a family-friendly dining experience that offers great food without breaking the bank. From the very start, Buckeye Pizza aimed to create a space where residents could come together, enjoy delicious meals, and savor the blend of traditional recipes with a local twist. The generous portions and vibrant menu reflect the restaurant's commitment to quality, delivering fresh ingredients and homemade flavors in every dish.

Each pizza starts with a house-made dough, hand-stretched to perfection and baked in a pan to ensure a crispy crust. Seasonal ingredients also inspire various menu items, keeping the offerings exciting and fresh for regular visitors. Buckeye Pizza prides itself on a welcoming atmosphere, making it ideal for family outings, date nights, or simply grabbing a quick bite with friends. Frequent events, such as trivia nights and local sports broadcasts, encourage community participation, drawing in crowds eager to share laughs and stories over a shared love of pizza.

In addition, the staff members work diligently to build relationships with patrons, remembering their names and favorite orders, which fosters a sense of belonging. So, whether it’s the vibrant neighborhood atmosphere, the delicious food, or the dedication to customer satisfaction, Buckeye Pizza continues to thrive as a local gem within Plain City.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-9 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-9 PM
  • Wednesday4-9 PM
  • Thursday4-9 PM
  • Friday4-10 PM
  • Saturday4-10 PM

Buckeye Pizza boasts diverse menu options designed to please every palate. Diners can indulge in a variety of appetizers such as cheesy garlic bread, beer-battered mushrooms, and mozzarella sticks that complement any meal. Salads like the chef salad and grilled chicken salad offer lighter fare, perfect for those seeking a fresh crunch or a healthy option. The subs also stand out with an impressive array— from the hearty Italian sausage sub to the versatile chicken BLT.

With a total of 21 delectable plates, including specialty pizzas like BBQ chicken and meat lovers, there’s something here for everyone. Community members often gather for game nights and events, making this pizzeria a central hub for social connections in Plain City.

Buckeye Pizza

The exterior of Buckeye Pizza displays a charming, welcoming front that invites guests inside. With its classic red and white color scheme and bright signage, the restaurant stands out on W Bigelow Ave. Outdoor seating provides a cozy space to enjoy a meal while soaking up the nearby community atmosphere. Locals often gather outside, turning a simple meal into a social experience. The vibe is casual and friendly, echoing the spirit of Plain City itself—inviting and warm.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

The pizza is great tasting for a great price! Some people who work there aren't too friendly but most are.

B
Bryce E.

I have read all the lukewarm reviews for this place. However, HANDS DOWN, their pizza was awesome. Buckeye Pizza's thin crust was PERFECT. It was NOT overly greasy, it was crunchy and just GREAT. The Pan was a DREAM. I ordered both. Their wings were pretty good.. OVERALL.. GREAT dinner. I ordered it over the phone, they said it'd be done in 25 mins. I got there 5 mins early, and my pan pizza was still in the oven. They had order in front of me and behind me, but my order was ready when they said it would be. I know that Plain City has ALOT of pizza places, but Buckeye is one of my go to for a while.

G
Gary D.

Delicious pizza and subs! Flavor is spot on and they don't skimp on toppings. Staff is super friendly and restaurant is kept clean.

B
B K.

Do yourself a favor and order some food from here!! The BBQ chicken pizza is absolutely amazing. They also have buckeye brownies. Will definitely be back!!!

S
Shaun M.

We love Liz's crust made fresh daily! Excellent pizza, ample toppings

L
Lila W.

So delicious pizza. I recommend this place 100% So good and very friendly people!

J
Jose M.